[ April 25, 2024 ]
Money quotes from today's ruling:
"The AFDI Ad is not only protected speech—it is core political speech. The Ad expresses AFDI’s pro-Israel perspective on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict in the Middle East, and implicitly calls for a pro-Israel U.S. foreign policy with regard to that conflict. The AFDI Ad is, further, a form of response to political ads on the same subject that have appeared in the same space. As such, the AFDI Ad is afforded the highest level of protection under the First Amendment." Judge Engelmayor's ruling today
(“At the heart of the First Amendment is the recognition of the fundamental importance of the free flow of ideas and opinions on matters of public interest and concern.”)
Story continues below advertisement
"The Court, therefore, analyzes plaintiffs’ claim that MTA violated the First Amendment in rejecting the AFDI Ad “against the background of a profound national commitment to the principle that debate on public issues should be uninhibited, robust, and wide-open."
Whatever weight might be assigned to the governmental interest in banning demeaning speech on the exterior of New York City buses on an even-handed basis, there is no good reason for protecting some individuals and groups, but not others, from such abuse. MTA’s no- demeaning standard, as currently formulated, is, therefore, inconsistent with the First Amendment.
To be sure, there are likely adherents to Jihad who are non-Muslims, such that the Ad can
literally be read to assail as savages all adherents to Jihad regardless of their religion—much as there assuredly are many adherents to Islam who do not accept Jihad, at least when defined as a violent crusade against enemies generally, or against Israel specifically. But, realistically, when it is read as a reasonable person would, the AFDI Ad plainly depicts Muslims—the primary adherents to this tenet of Islam—as “savages.”
Pamela Geller, Robert Muise (AFLC), David Yerushalmi (AFLC) and Robert Spencer
AFDI triumphed in our lawsuit against the NYC MTA's ban on our pro-Israel ad. We won on all points. Straight down the line. Judge Engelmayer wrote a wonderful opinion. Brilliant. And AFDI is now on the law books. Freedom, freedom, freedom …… the sweet, delicious taste of it.
This is a great victory for the First Amendment. The freedom of speech is increasingly threatened in the U.S. in recent years — the Left and Islamic supremacists are doing all they can to rule honest discussion of Islamic jihad violence and Jew-hatred out of the realm of acceptable public discourse. Judge Engelmayer has struck a huge blow against this sinister authoritarian effort and for the freedom of speech that is the cornerstone of all our freedoms.
It is a super opinion. Read it here. Download Opinion
Truth will not be suppressed or embargoed.
Illustrating the MTA’s inconsistency, Engelmayer noted that “under MTA’s no-demeaning standard, an advertiser willing to pay for the privilege is today at liberty to place a demeaning ad on the side or back of a city bus that states any of the following: ‘Southerners are bigots’; ‘Upper West Siders are elitist snobs’; ‘Fat people are slobs’; ‘Blondes are bimbos’; ‘Lawyers are sleazebags’; or ‘The store clerks at Gristedes are rude and lazy.’”
“In light of that, disallowing a pro-Israel ad was clearly a politically correct, politically motivated denial of free speech,” said Pamela Geller, Executive Director of the American Freedom Defense Initiative. “As such, Judge Engelamyer’s decision is crucial not just for AFDI and the MTA, but for the freedom of speech in general,” “The AFDI case has set a key legal precedent for the freedom of speech and won a great victory for the First Amendment.”
Geller added: “The freedom of speech is increasingly threatened in the U.S. in recent years — the Left and Islamic supremacists are doing all they can to rule honest discussion of Islamic jihad violence and Jew-hatred out of the realm of acceptable public discourse. Judge Engelmayer has struck a huge blow against this sinister authoritarian effort and for the freedom of speech that is the cornerstone of all our freedoms. Truth will not be suppressed or embargoed.”
"This is an important case with serious constitutional ramifications for free speech not only in New York, but across the country," said Robert Muise, co-founder of American Freedom Law Center. "This opinion is extremely well-written, well-considered and will go down as an important decision protecting Free Speech on government property."
AFLC Victory: New York Federal Court Strikes Down “Demeaning” Speech Restriction; MTA Must Run Advertisement Opposing Jihad and Supporting Israel
New York, New York (July 20, 2012) — Earlier today, Federal Judge Paul A. Engelmayer, sitting in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, ruled that the New York Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s (MTA) restriction on “demeaning” speech was unconstitutional. The MTA had refused to run an anti-jihad advertisement that, according to the MTA, referred to Israel’s enemies as savages who engaged in jihad. The MTA flagged the advertisement that was set to run on the exterior of its buses, claiming that it violated the MTA’s policy against displaying “images or information that demean an individual or group of individuals on account of race, color, religion, national origin, ancestry, gender, age, disability or sexual orientation.”
The court struck down the MTA’s speech restriction as a violation of the First Amendment because the MTA, as a governmental agency, was permitting politically controversial speech, even demeaning speech, but not speech that demeaned specific groups or individuals that fit within the MTA’s protected classes (in this case, Muslims embracing savage jihad).
This ruling came as a result of a lawsuit filed by the American Freedom Law Center (AFLC) on behalf of the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI), Pamela Geller, and Robert Spencer, challenging the speech restriction and requesting that the court strike it down and order the MTA to run the advertisement.
The specific advertisement, which sparked the controversy, states, “In Any War Between the Civilized Man and the Savage, Support the Civilized Man. Support Israel. Defeat Jihad.”
This advertisement was offered as a direct response to an anti-Israel advertisement that was displayed on MTA property by a pro-Palestine group. The MTA approved the anti-Israel advertisement, which portrayed the Palestinians as being on the side of “peace and justice.” However, the MTA rejected AFDI’s advertisement, claiming that it violated its “demeaning” speech restriction.
Robert Muise, Co-Founder and Senior Counsel of AFLC, commented: “The court’s ruling is exactly right. As a governmental agency that is subject to the requirements of the Constitution, the MTA cannot allow speech on the controversial subject of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict and then pick and choose which messages are acceptable and which are not based on the content of the message or the viewpoint of the speaker. By doing so, the MTA is violating a fundamental principle of the First Amendment.”
As argued in the lawsuit, the MTA is mandated as a governmental agency to comply with federal and state laws, including the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution, which prohibit the government from making content- and viewpoint-based restrictions on speech.
David Yerushalmi, Co-Founder and Senior Counsel of AFLC, noted: “The court found that our client’s advertisement attacking savages who engage in jihad against Israel could be understood to be demeaning to those Muslims who support violent jihad against Israel. But the response to that is – so what? And that is effectively what the court said. The First Amendment is not designed to protect just polite, politically correct speech that offends no one. The First Amendment was specifically designed to protect those who dare challenge the political orthodoxy by quite rationally linking Islam’s sharia-mandated jihad against the ‘infidel’ Christians and Jews who dare occupy any part of the world that Islam claims as its own.”
Yerushalmi added, “Indeed, we have just recently learned how even the FBI and the military are afraid to investigate connections between Islam's jihad and violence, and it was this fear and politically correct censorship by FBI agents that permitted Major Hasan to carry-on a dialogue about jihad against infidels with the known terrorist Anwar al-Awlaki until Hassan ultimately acted on his sharia-mandated jihad and murdered 13 Americans and wounded 29 others.”
UPDATE: NY TIMES here:
The Truth Must be Told
Your contribution supports independent journalism
Please take a moment to consider this. Now, more than ever, people are reading Geller Report for news they won't get anywhere else. But advertising revenues have all but disappeared. Google Adsense is the online advertising monopoly and they have banned us. Social media giants like Facebook and Twitter have blocked and shadow-banned our accounts. But we won't put up a paywall. Because never has the free world needed independent journalism more.
Everyone who reads our reporting knows the Geller Report covers the news the media won't. We cannot do our ground-breaking report without your support. We must continue to report on the global jihad and the left's war on freedom. Our readers’ contributions make that possible.
Geller Report's independent, investigative journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce. But we do it because we believe our work is critical in the fight for freedom and because it is your fight, too.
Please contribute here.
or
Make a monthly commitment to support The Geller Report – choose the option that suits you best.
Quick note: We cannot do this without your support. Fact. Our work is made possible by you and only you. We receive no grants, government handouts, or major funding.Tech giants are shutting us down. You know this. Twitter, LinkedIn, Google Adsense, Pinterest permanently banned us. Facebook, Google search et al have shadow-banned, suspended and deleted us from your news feeds. They are disappearing us. But we are here.
Subscribe to Geller Report newsletter here— it’s free and it’s essential NOW when informed decision making and opinion is essential to America's survival. Share our posts on your social channels and with your email contacts. Fight the great fight.
Follow Pamela Geller on Gettr. I am there. click here.
Follow Pamela Geller on Trump's social media platform, Truth Social. It's open and free.
Remember, YOU make the work possible. If you can, please contribute to Geller Report.
Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.
We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spammy or unhelpful, click the - symbol under the comment to let us know. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.
If you would like to join the conversation, but don't have an account, you can sign up for one right here.
If you are having problems leaving a comment, it's likely because you are using an ad blocker, something that break ads, of course, but also breaks the comments section of our site. If you are using an ad blocker, and would like to share your thoughts, please disable your ad blocker. We look forward to seeing your comments below.
37 Comments
11 years ago
God bless you all in this fight for freedom.
11 years ago
Congratulations! Very inspiring, and a victory for free people everywhere, enabling them to speak up against murderous savages in these United States. I’ll send my donation to AFDI today. Very proud of your work.
11 years ago
Very good news.
11 years ago
Three cheers for Freedom of Speech. Thank you Pamela and the AFDI for fighting the good fight. Islam does not allow freedom of speech. We must never allow Islam and organizations like CAIR to push their demands to silence those who speak the truth about the evils of Islam and sharia law.
11 years ago
This made my day! Congratulations and thanks to Pamela and AFDI!
11 years ago
Very many Congratulations to all concerned, but HOW sad that this case was needed,
in the “Land of the Free and Home of the Brave”.
Read Gatestone Institute today about France – CHILLING.
11 years ago
Congratulations Pamela, and thank you for pressing the issue. Your hardwork and commitment to freedom is deeply appreciated. Please don’t stop. Please don’t ever lose heart.
May God bless you, and keep you safe.
11 years ago
BRAVO! Thanks to all involved who worked/work so hard for freedom.
11 years ago
Hallelu Yah!
11 years ago
Wow! Pamela
A victory for you great lady. You are the Mordechai Anielewicz of America. These words could very well apply to you:
“The courage, idealism, and strong leadership abilities of Mordechai Anielewicz helped iniate the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising, the single largest Jewish armed resistance against the Nazis during the Holocaust.
Emmanuel Ringelblum, the Warsaw Ghetto archivist, wrote several biographical sketches of some of the leading personalities of the Warsaw Ghetto, including the following about Mordechai Aneilewicz:
Mordechai threw himself into the defense activity with all his zeal. Together with other groups and parties the Fighters’ Organization was created, at whose head the coordinating commission of the political organization placed Comrade Mordechai. …Mordechai was the soul of the organization, one of its most devoted workers.
11 years ago
Congratulations and thank you.
11 years ago
This my me too to Susan Duclos thoughts.
11 years ago
CONGRATULATIONS to you and all who fought this! It’s insane that we live in a time when one has to wage such battles, but wage them we must and you Pamela Geller on leading the charge. Thank you is hardly adequate to express the gratitude I feel to you, Robert Spencer, and you legal team.
11 years ago
MAZEL TOV TO PAMELA GELLER AND COMPANY! CERTAINLY A JOB WELL DONE.
BUT NOW AN INTERESTING QUESTION.
WILL MTA OBEY THE LAW AND RUN THE ADS ?
STAY TUNED.
11 years ago
Obama calls Hezbollah barbaric terrorists but you can’t call them savages.
WaPo: Obama condemns ‘barbaric terrorist attack’ on Israelis in Bulgaria.
11 years ago
…. Well, you can now
11 years ago
Excellent. Extreme kudos to Pamela and to others who helped.
Now, design a new ad campaign. We can do much better than that existing ad.
11 years ago
Just heard about this on 1010WINS on my way home from work! YIPPEEE! Congratulations and thank you from the bottom of my heart for your tireless work in defending our most precious of rights!
11 years ago
Awesome! Thank you!
11 years ago
Congratulations, Pamela! This victory is most welcome and most heartening. God bless you all.
11 years ago
Baruch Ha’Shem!
11 years ago
Congratulations to yuo and for freedom of speech.
11 years ago
afforded the highest level of protection
music to my ears!
11 years ago
Congratulations on the victory. And thanks to you and your team for putting in the effort.
11 years ago
I’m adding my congrats to you Pam and the wonderful AFDI team. What a great victory for freedom of speech. I just hope the ruling is final and that the barbarians don’t intimidate the MTA to try to get the judge’s decision reversed on the grounds that he has a Jewish sounding name and therefore was biased. Who knows, they’ll try anything, but perhaps I’m just being pessimistic!
11 years ago
Adding my congrats Pam and to the wonderful AFDI team. What a great victory for free speech. However, one thing that bothers me – I just hope the barbarians don’t intimidate the MTA into trying to appeal and reverse the decision on the grounds that the judge has a Jewish sounding name,and was therefore biased. They’ll stoop to any trick in the book, but perhaps I’m just being pessimistic. G-D BLESS YOU ALL.
11 years ago
Mazal tov!!!!!! Wonderful news!!!! It does not matter that I am a Canadian – we are all in this fight together!!!! Thank you to those who fought so hard for this!
11 years ago
Congratulations, Pamela. It’s so wonderful, so refreshing, to see such a sane and thoughtful judgement, in contrast to the daily fare of outrageous and politically correct pandering to Islamic supremacists.
You and your supporters have worked hard for this victory.
We all join with you in celebrating this achievement which confirms freedom of speech is still alive.
11 years ago
I got goosebumps reading that!! What a hard fought fight for free speech!! Wonderful job from all involved. There aren’t even words to express my appreciation for what you have all done. It’s endless. Thank you!
11 years ago
The NY Slimes article quotes the judge’s decision in part as: “…as long as it demeaned a group not included in the prohibited list.” What “prohibited list”? This is political doublespeak that just invites the muslo-nazis to lobby hard to get any word associated w/islam added to the “prohibited list”.
11 years ago
Pamela,
When my great-great-grandsons and daughters utter their first recognition of their mother’s dear face, and say: “Momma!” They will have said that as a FREE American
babe… thanks to you, and your fellow warriors for freedom.
11 years ago
Congratulations! It’s a good news for freedom lovers.
11 years ago
Pam you go girl/ and Robert you go man. and to all that fought so hard for this. and lets not for get the judge we need to thank him. maybe this is one judge that knows what this country is all about. freedom.
11 years ago
Thanks Pamela. This news made my day!
Three cheers for Freedom of Speech. Thank you Pamela and the AFDI for fighting the good fight. Islam does not allow freedom of speech. We must never allow leftists Islam and organizations like CAIR to push their demands to silence and those who speak the truth about the evils of Islam and sharia law.
11 years ago
You have struck a blow not simply for freedom of speech—the cornerstone of the US Constitution—but also for freedom from fear, freedom from the shackles of political correctness, freedom from the perversions of progressive/Islamic bigotry, freedom from terror. You are heroes, one and all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
11 years ago
God Bless America and her staunch defenders! Thank you so for your investments on my childrens’ behalf. I haven’t time to summon all my adjectives, please know the admiration, respect and love we shall always hold for you. Victory!
9 years ago
Freedom of speech won this round. Sharia law is down but not out.
