[ April 18, 2024 ]
The real story is Harvard’s refusal to release the name. The left and its unconditional defense and protection of savages.
“Harvard Law School is declining to disclose the identity of a student who repeatedly accused former Israeli foreign minister Tzipi Livni of being ‘smelly’ during a public discussion, a description many have described as anti-Semitic.” (source)
Shocka. It was a Muslim. But if an Islamic dictator were there (like Ahmadinejad at Columbia), they would be kissing his shoe.
Story continues below advertisement
Meet The Brilliant Harvard Student Who Called A Jewish Politician ‘Smelly’ By Blake Neff, Daily Caller, April 22, 2016:
At an event run by Harvard’s Program on Negotiation last Thursday, current Zionist Union MK and former foreign minister Tzipi Livni was confronted with an unusual, but nonetheless noxious question from a Harvard Law School student in attendance.
In a panel section of the event, co-sponsored by the Jewish Law Students Association and Harvard Hillel, the student asked Livni: “How is it that you are so smelly?”
When his pungent question only elicited curious looks, he clarified: “Oh, it’s a question about the odor of Ms. Tzipi Livni, very smelly, and I was just wondering.” (J Post)
Harking back to the old anti-Semitic trope of the “smelly Jew” was roundly condemned in the Harvard Law Record on Tuesday.
The name of the Harvard student who asked a visiting Israeli politician why she was “so smelly” has been revealed. The student is a leader in Harvard’s Arab community with a history of anti-Israeli activism. Not only that, but he’s also a man looking for a job, making his public stunt look like an incredibly bad idea.
Last week, Husam El-Qoulaq rudely disrupted a panel featuring Israeli politician Tzipi Livni to ask her why she was “so smelly.”
“I’m question (sic) about the odor of Tzipi Livni, very smelly, and I was just wondering,” El-Qoulaq said to a confused panel.
Despite his remarks being very public, it took nearly a week before El-Qoulaq’s statements attracted wider notice, with several Jewish media outlets expressing outrage at the stunt on Wednesday. Harvard Law School Dean Martha Minow strongly condemned the behavior in a school-wide email. El-Qoulaq issued an apology as well, claiming he was unaware that assigning a pungent odor to Jewish people has long been a part of anti-Semitic propaganda. El-Qoulaq suggested that he was just trying to make a rude personal attack on Livni rather than an attack on all Jews in general.
But despite the fact that the “smelly” question was made at a very public event with numerous eyewitnesses, Harvard and others have tried very hard to suppress El-Qoulaq’s identity. His name wasn’t included in Minow’s email condemnation, it wasn’t added to his apology in the Harvard Law Record (despite his invitation to have offended Harvard students reach out to him), and a video recording of the event was even censored to take out his question, thereby preventing it from aiding in his identification.
It wasn’t enough, though. On Wednesday night, Qoulaq’s identity was announced by writer and pro-Israel advocate Noah Pollak, who said he confirmed Qoulaq’s identity with multiple eyewitnesses.
Harvard Law student who made anti-Semitic statement to Livni is named Husam El-Coolaq. Harvard trying to conceal his ID. A campus BDS leader
— Noah Pollak (@NoahPollak) April 20, 2016
El-Qoulaq (whose surname is also spelled El-Coolaq) is in his third year at Harvard Law (after getting into the school at just 20 years old) and is a leader with the group Harvard Law School Justice for Palestine.
Since news of his stunt began spreading, El-Qoulaq has been hastily scrubbing his online presence. His Twitter account has disappeared, as has his LinkedIn profile (though it still appears in Google searches), and he also deleted a profile on the business start-up website Angel. Not only that, but a profile of El-Qoulaq has been scrubbed from the page of the Harvard Arab Students Association (compare the current version with this recent screengrab).
El-Qoulaq’s online efforts may be related to a desire to avoid being toxic on the job market, since he is just days away from graduating.
“Husam would like the attendees of Harvard Arab Weekend to know that he is actively soliciting any and all offers of employment, with a slight preference for those that would keep him a safe distance away from the legal profession,” his now-vanished profile said.
Notably, Qoulaq’s Livni stunt isn’t the first time he’s been linked to the disruption of an Israeli speaker. In 2010, 11 students at the University of California, Irvine were arrested for disrupting a speech by Israeli ambassador Michael Oren. In 2011, Qoulaq took part in a protest at the University of California, Berkeley supporting them, saying their arrest was part of an effort to “quell the Palestinian narrative.”
El-Qoulaq did not respond to The Daily Caller News Foundation’s request for comment.
The Truth Must be Told
Your contribution supports independent journalism
Please take a moment to consider this. Now, more than ever, people are reading Geller Report for news they won't get anywhere else. But advertising revenues have all but disappeared. Google Adsense is the online advertising monopoly and they have banned us. Social media giants like Facebook and Twitter have blocked and shadow-banned our accounts. But we won't put up a paywall. Because never has the free world needed independent journalism more.
Everyone who reads our reporting knows the Geller Report covers the news the media won't. We cannot do our ground-breaking report without your support. We must continue to report on the global jihad and the left's war on freedom. Our readers’ contributions make that possible.
Geller Report's independent, investigative journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce. But we do it because we believe our work is critical in the fight for freedom and because it is your fight, too.
Please contribute here.
or
Make a monthly commitment to support The Geller Report – choose the option that suits you best.
Quick note: We cannot do this without your support. Fact. Our work is made possible by you and only you. We receive no grants, government handouts, or major funding.Tech giants are shutting us down. You know this. Twitter, LinkedIn, Google Adsense, Pinterest permanently banned us. Facebook, Google search et al have shadow-banned, suspended and deleted us from your news feeds. They are disappearing us. But we are here.
Subscribe to Geller Report newsletter here— it’s free and it’s essential NOW when informed decision making and opinion is essential to America's survival. Share our posts on your social channels and with your email contacts. Fight the great fight.
Follow Pamela Geller on Gettr. I am there. click here.
Follow Pamela Geller on Trump's social media platform, Truth Social. It's open and free.
Remember, YOU make the work possible. If you can, please contribute to Geller Report.
Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.
We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spammy or unhelpful, click the - symbol under the comment to let us know. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.
If you would like to join the conversation, but don't have an account, you can sign up for one right here.
If you are having problems leaving a comment, it's likely because you are using an ad blocker, something that break ads, of course, but also breaks the comments section of our site. If you are using an ad blocker, and would like to share your thoughts, please disable your ad blocker. We look forward to seeing your comments below.
117 Comments
7 years ago
We all know that if a leader of a Muslim country were asked the same question, the media and the Left would be all over it, crying about “racism” and “Islamophobia”.
7 years ago
Reply to
Anneke9
Wait, it’s because of Others’ ‘racism’ & islamofauxbia that muslim leaders Smell so Bad?! Lol!
7 years ago
Reply to
Anneke9
My guess is the student would be expelled by now for a political correctness violation. I think Harvard actually has such a rule.
7 years ago
My Jewish wife of 32 years smell just fine, thank you. I have never met a Jew who was “smelly” because, as a general rule, they practice good personal hygiene, unlike every Arab immigrant I have ever met. I used to have them in my office for job interviews and couldn’t wait until they left. I think they bathe once a week, tops. Please pass this along to the condescending, insulting Harvard Law student, who might have a high IQ but now people skills whatsoever. Can’t wait to see him in court. Gonna lose a lot of cases.
7 years ago
Reply to
Kelvinator
Hey there, asshole. My girlfriend is a Christian Arab from Lebanon and she smells just fine. You should learn to distinguish between skanky Muslims and good Christian Arabs who have lived in the US since the early 20th century and still immigrate here today. You stink. Luckily, I have many good Jewish friends so I know they are not all bigots like you.
7 years ago
Reply to
wilypagan
Excuse me, snowflake. It’s called illustrating absurdity by being absurd. This student asks a total stranger who came to his campus why she is smelly. Of course I don’t think all Arabs are smelly. I dated, and almost married a Lebanese Arab Christian and almost married her. So how does it feel to be insulted by a stranger? Not very good, does it. But this arrogant law students is quite proud of himself for offending the sensibilities of a good and decent woman who came to educate him
7 years ago
Reply to
wilypagan
Since 1890 to about about 1910, most have assimilated, John Sununu, Issa Hutchison, George Mitchell, Judge Jeanine Pirro, to name just a few. Most highly successful business people, Maronite Christians, and yes, as I, are very proud of our heritage and America first and support, as I, again Israel first. To be more technical. Lebanese Maronite Christians are not really Arabs, they are descendants of the Phonecians, and the people who sailed to the edges of the world and yes established Carthage, along with coming to the new world , here, in the far distant past. Lebanese Maronite Christians, spoke Aramaic, language of Christ. Over the centuries they had to adopt the Arabic language because of the predominance of Arabs.
7 years ago
Reply to
Kelvinator
He will only see shari’a court, then get stoned for insulting the judge.
7 years ago
Reply to
Kelvinator
And using their left hand as a substitute for toilet tissue doesn’t bode well either, especially if they work in restaurants, food processing plantts or hospitals.
7 years ago
Reply to
Judi
That disgusting practice instantly stops Muslims and Arabs from working in any business that serves the public. Hotels, resorts, airlines, taxis, stores, banks.
The idea that he can be considered to work in a law occupation is ridiculous. Islam hates democracy, yet there is now a female Muslim judge in New York. Oxymoron.
If anyone had been close to this El-Qoulaq, they would have discovered he likely smells like a pig’s ass, possibly because of recent sex.
D
7 years ago
Reply to
Judi
yes the most hygenic reason to never never eat in a Muslim restaurant nor to eat any Hal-al food.
7 years ago
El Coolaq, whose surname is spelled: d-o-u-c-h-e-b-a-g !
7 years ago
What the hell happened to Harvard?
7 years ago
Reply to
wilypagan
EXACTLY!!!
There ought to be an expose of this fact. To date, they have donated $200 billion toward funding construction of mosques throughout the West, including endowments to ‘prestigious’ schools like Harvard.
7 years ago
I’ve known many Jews and never noticed any odors, except that the ones I have met smelled very good (ie, the women smelled really nice)…especially the Israeli women.
Can’t say the same for all of the Arabs I have met…many of whom don’t seem to believe in deodorants. Or apparently baths.
7 years ago
Reply to
JSebastian
Well I have met very smelly Jews and they are orthodox. I used to be orthodox Jew and smelly, now I have shower. Tomorrow I am clean.
7 years ago
Reply to
JSebastian
Yes. Try sitting next to a Muslim/muslima on a hot day on public transport. You need a gas mask!
7 years ago
Tzipi Livni might be smelly but still I Lick her p.ssy. She is hot and no muzzrat wa.ker can touch her.
7 years ago
I would like to rub this dog’s nose in it!
7 years ago
With an intellectual capability like that (in Law at 20), we had better watch this one carefully.
Let’s keep this incident alive on the Internet forever. Any good places to post it?
7 years ago
Reply to
El Cid
Don’t know how intellectual capable this piece of filth is because they get moved along the grading lines with all the influence of the AA crowd.
7 years ago
Reply to
El Cid
Is he smart, which is not indicated by his actions, or paid for admission?
7 years ago
It’s irresponsible & unconscionable that a person that glorifies the anti-human rights & anti Afro racist paragraphs of Muhammad should work in the profession of law. This proves that the constitution & the values of society must be reevaluated. Condemn Muhammad. Ban Muhammadism!
7 years ago
It is because pigs have a keen sense of smell.
7 years ago
Reply to
gallowaygrumblefield
I wish Tzipi would have responded with your great one liner, but she is probably too much of a diplomat.
7 years ago
Reply to
gallowaygrumblefield
Tzipi Livni should have told this worthless Muslim son-of-a-pig to stop smelling his own armpits.
It’s amazing the way in which Muslims have lowered dialogue to such depths. Childish insults and lies is their way, but then just consider who is their role model, Mohammad, a worthless savage, messenger to a satanic, criminal god. They are, with few exceptions, devoid of grace or decorum, filled with intolerance, hatred, bigotry laced with a huge dose of stupidity. That Westerners now placate and capitulate to such people manifest the eroding of values effect of contemporary liberalism that now equates to a form of mental illness. How else do we explain this covering for disgusting people?
7 years ago
That “smell” is called, “clean” because she did something he hasn’t done in weeks, she bathes regularly.
7 years ago
Reply to
Dr. Doomsday
haha, right, when confronted with clean, he didn’t know what to make of it.
7 years ago
An American student should have had his place at Harvard. Vote Trump and deport all followers of the pedophile.
7 years ago
How does someone of obvious low intelligence get into a University in the first place?
That is something that a seven year old would use as an insult!
7 years ago
Reply to
Crystal Waters
Institutions are know by the quality of students they graduate. harvard graduates feces, it is an academic dung heap.
7 years ago
Reply to
Crystal Waters
Of course it’s not. Saudi Arabia has invested millions of dollars in it.
7 years ago
Reply to
Mahou Shoujo
YES!!! wiping all that shiittyy Saudi money with their left hands on Arab “scholars” such as this one whose most cogent argument having seized the microphone is that someone was “smelly”. He was obviously smelling himself – can’t smell past his own stench!
Happy to be represented by people like this, harvard is a dung heap, its “scholarship” a thing of the past.
It’s Israeli universities that come out with all the REAL innovations and cures and thinking to better mankind.
7 years ago
Reply to
Dravaa
harvard has disgraced itself and academia on other occasions, it is little better than a shopping mall store front community college, riding on a long past reputation.
7 years ago
Reply to
Logic PrObe
It could have a lot to do with the hundreds of millions donated to the university by Saudi Arabia.
7 years ago
Reply to
Logic PrObe
He gets into Harvard because Harvard has been poisoned with foolish Leftist “leadership”. Harvard has deliberately dumbed down its standards for Third world people….who Harvard puts on a pedestal.
7 years ago
Reply to
Logic PrObe
It certainly makes you question the value of an Ivy League education, doesn’t it?
7 years ago
now imagine the outrage if someone had asked a Muslim politician if he smelled.
7 years ago
Reason No. 5785 not to hire a Muslim.
7 years ago
Harvard is an academic gutter that smells of grovelling dhimmi. Lawyers are fairly low on the evolutionary scale, muslim lawyers, even lower. Then there are palestinians, they are at the bottom of sewer dregs. No wonder everyone sees palestinians with disgust, look at how they behave in public towards people on the street.
7 years ago
The Arabs are also Semite. : If Mary and Joseph tried to reach Bethlehem today, they would get stuck at an Israeli checkpoint. Why is it that the plight of persecuted Christians in the Iraq and Syria has attracted the attention and anger of the West, yet the Christians of Palestine don’t get a look-in?
Arab Christians, and specifically Palestinian Christians, have always been at the forefront of efforts to resist Israeli expansionism: from politicians such as Hanan Ashrawi to diplomats such as Afif Safieh, who served as the PLO’s envoy in London, Washington and Moscow; from the New York-based academic Edward Said to the militant leader George Habash, who founded the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. The current mayor of Bethlehem is Vera Baboun, a Palestinian Christian who has written of “the despair of decades of living under a foreign occupation”. The Palestinian ambassador to the UK, Manuel Hassassian, is Christian, too. “We as Christians are part and parcel of the social fabric of [Palestinian] society, I want to celebrate Christmas in a free country.”
Palestinian church leaders – Catholic, Anglican, Lutheran, Greek Orthodox – came together in 2009 to declare the occupation a “sin against God” and urge a boycott of Israel. What a contrast with US evangelical leaders who shamefully line up behind right-wing Israeli governments and Jewish settlers as they wait for Armageddon.
Palestinian Christians complicate the simplistic narrative of “Muslims v Jews”; they are an inconvenient reminder that the conflict in the Holy Land has nothing to do with theology and everything to do with freedom and self-determination. Whatever your view of Jesus or Muhammad, if you are a Palestinian resident of the West Bank you are a victim of the longest military occupation in the world.
7 years ago
Reply to
N.Wildstar
If you are a palestinian muslim, you are a subhuman violent demon worshiper. As all the news coming out of palestine concerns muslim violence towards Jews, your lies about Christian palestinians are just that. When palestinians have days of peace instead of days of rage, you will have started on the long road to human decency.
7 years ago
Reply to
N.Wildstar
“Israeli expansionism”? That’s a laugh – they’re the only country actually giving their land away, getting smaller every decade. It’s the Muslims always expanding, expanding, now they’re swarming Europe.
You’ve bought all the lies hook line and sinker, sucker. Too many to refute to deaf ears – waste of time.
7 years ago
Muzzies wipe butt with bare hands. Not only they are smelly, they are full of germs. Just one more reason not to shake hands with Muzzies http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Muslim-Butt-Wipe
7 years ago
What a surprise it was a savage !
No room in a civilized society for islam
7 years ago
Boycott moslums
7 years ago
What a surprise it was a Muslim who made the stupid comment.
Actually it is really no surprise. I have come to expect nothing from Muslims except, hate death and destruction. The only things Muslims seem to be good at.
If I was Tzipy Livni I wouldn’t care afterall take it where it is coming from a stinky Muslim.
Jew hatred is in their DNA and they learn it from the Quran.
7 years ago
I wonder what Harvard’s reaction would have been if this Moslem
had accused a black person of being smelly?
7 years ago
We all know why Muslims smell like goats…
7 years ago
Reply to
Mahou Shoujo
Subhuman muslims get pleasure out of violence, when they get to hell they will be violently displeasured by their demon.
7 years ago
Why have these pigs been invited into our countries to attend our universities, exploit our systems, work in immigration, politics, media and law? Its disgusting. They never evolve, never improve, never learn anything. Just throw these Muslims out.
7 years ago
Talk about “people with glass houses shouldn’t be throwing stones”. This guy Husam looks like he needs to take a shower and clean himself up! Starting with his brain. I am sick and tired of America and Western Europe taking these Third World trouble makers in.
D
7 years ago
He should be dismissed from the university without degree and permission to be re-admitted.
He has taken down now his LinkedIn profile.
7 years ago
Reply to
guost
Then the school will lose the lawsuit. The ACLU would love for that to happen so that the school can be slammed with a lawsuit that the ACLU (for whom he used to work) would likely win.
7 years ago
From all the reeking muslime “exchange students” I have encountered it is more than hypocritical that he ask this question. A goat cannot smell it’s own ass.
7 years ago
pot calling the kettle black. How can this piece of sh(t smell better than her……
7 years ago
This “ACHWHEAT” is a “SHARMUTA” for the geto scum around Israel. I’m sure he will read this post,. Ack a sub, , you eat our food, enjoy our freedoms, you are a dredge of society, nothing will take the smell of goats from you. Kess emick , byeck siteck, gideck,etc.
7 years ago
This from the filthiest cockroaches on the planet with no conception of personal hygiene. You can smell them a mile away, especially the females in their bags.
7 years ago
Everyhing is smelly to muslems because they wipe their butt with their bare left hand and then pick there nose with the same hand.
7 years ago
Reply to
Neil Hatch
They also wash them afterwards but you know leave out tidbits to insult masses. Also keep in mind that they use only the left hand because it is impure. Should that cultural aspect maybe be updated to include tp? Sure, but that isn’t the point here anyway. The guy let his prejudice dictate his behaviour which will end in however his karma falls. He was obnoxious in his actions and it was unwarranted.
7 years ago
She was being a Muslim for a day. That’s why she smelled.
7 years ago
For now on, he will be known as smelly Husam.
7 years ago
Good that he was smoked out. he’s be commercial poison for anyone who’d hire him.
7 years ago
“he’s also a man looking for a job, making his public stunt look like an incredibly bad idea.”
– Not sure why he is worried. There will be plenty of Progressive organizations that will be happy to hire him. Besides there will be Muslims who see him as a hero and will be able to find him a suitable position. Then there is always the Middle East.
7 years ago
The real story is Harvard’s refusal to release the name. The left and its unconditional defense and protection of savages.
============
The core of the whole article.
Europe is far worse.
Just read on this blog for the examples of islamic related crime and rape being held under the table by our governments.
The fact that the average left-liberal and their deep,warm, intimate befriending with the islam has a mutual, systematic and deeply embedded Jew-hatred in common, amongst others, is no coincidence.
I keep repeating how the saying goes in Holland: “The bullet comes from the left”.
7 years ago
It seems Muslims can openly spout antisemitism and nothing will happen to them- but complain about what they say, and you will get into trouble
7 years ago
She’s “smelly” he said, and excused himself to go to the restroom to wipe his own shiitte off his azz with his hands as Islam instructs. More “scholarshitte” from Harvard.
7 years ago
This comment from an Arabic student shows the deterioration of Harvard Univ. A friend of mine who was there on a sabbatical year told me that there are a lot of Arabic students from Saudi Arabia and the Golf, and they are paying a lot of money. After the first semester, most of them fail in the examinations. He was told by the university to ease the tests in order to make them pass the examinations. They are buying their degree with petrodollars. What a shame.
7 years ago
I think calling someone “smelly” is well within free speech.
The point of highlighting this scenario is the difference between the reaction of the community to incidents of whom is insulting whom. The moonbats flew into a rage when Ann Coulter said that muslims fly on magic carpets, which was equally free speech.
7 years ago
How can Harvard not expel this anti-Semitic swine from school and still expect to be looked upon as a credible institution of higher learning?
7 years ago
They say you eat what you Are. Stinking Goats
that graze on garbage served up in Shwarma’s
Platter’s of Goat & Rice etc. Wash up & Pray 5
Times a Day ..you still Stink.. pour on Dior or
Halston it just gets worse. Living in KSA …Money
won’t relieve that Smell.. I remember Well.
7 years ago
Wasn’t there a chairman at the meeting? Wasn’t that person capable of pointing out immediately that it was an offensive and inappropriate comment? Who was the chairman? Irrespective of the calibre of the bigot who has now been exposed.
7 years ago
I heard that he is a homosexual Muslim! Maybe he thinks the other Muslims won’t torture & murder him if he acts like a pit bull dog! I think they will!
7 years ago
Muzzrats are pretty much offensive to all five senses, I can smell this c*nt from behind my computer, phew!
7 years ago
how much muslim oil money is given to Harvard each year? how did this muslim get into Harvard law school, and was it the same way obola did, via Saudi money and influence? I’d be very interested if Harvard and all the ivies have sold their souls to the muslims for money
7 years ago
With the stink of the rotting corpses of islam in his nose, he cant smell how clean non muslims are.
7 years ago
Muslims stink to high heaven with their so called religion! Most need a bath ,which still can’t get their stink out! Pos
D
7 years ago
Soon to be another condescending Muslim Lawyer trained from birth to hate Torah – – as usual jealous of the better Jewish Lawyers trained from birth to love Torah…nothing new here.
7 years ago
Yes to Diversity
No to Islam
Islam means no Jews no Christians no Sikhs no Buddhists and no other religions either
No women,they must be sheeple or ELSE
Islam means no homosexuals ,restricted entertainment no freedom of speech
No criticism of the Moslem overlords,or their completely cruel prophet.No criticism of Sharia law which was dredged up from some hell to earth by an evil man and his bloodthirsty demon pretending to be the creator.
Believe me you can save yourself a lifetime of problems and if the possibiltity of your children of being born into slavery under sharia law by simply saying no to Muslim immigration.Be a little politically incorrect say no to Muslim immigration until someone puts Islam back in its cage.
